Tag: Being a DIK

  • Fuck Around and Find Out

    Fuck Around and Find Out

    The most tantalizing feature a story-based game can promise is »meaningful choices«. Choice and consequence is the unique narrative feature games bring to the table. A story that takes my agency into account and tailors the narrative to my specific experience? Where do I sign up?

    More often than not, the notion of meaningful choices with a variety of significant outcomes is an empty promise. A marketing line, not reflected in the game itself. »The illusion of choice« is probably more common than actual satisfying narrative divergence. Everyone remembers picking a colored ending in Mass Effect 3.

    So what if I told you that one of the most delicious platters of choice & consequence can be found in this amateur adult game?

    Not Safe

    In the summer of 2025 there was a big debacle when payment processors suddenly denied their service to storefronts like Steam and itch.io. This lead to extensive restrictions on adult and NSFW games. It was a whole thing and the last word has not been written on the global attempts at deplatforming adult material.

    In protest against digital censorship, GOG released a »Freedom to Buy Games« bundle for free, consisting of a package of adult games. I downloaded this bundle as my tiny show of solidarity. Suddenly I had this handful of, well… porn games, on my GOG account. I am not prudish, but it certainly felt a bit crass having Fetish Locator and Lust Theory standing there on display. Thankfully, you can hide games from your library, but doing so made me a tad embarrassed. These games are legitimate as creative expressions, even if their purpose might be a bit eh… crude.

    Instead of just tossing them away I should see if these concrete titles are actually worth all the fuzz (regardless of their right to exist). So I checked them out.

    For uh *cough* the Cause, of course.

    Jokes aside, most of these were not really to my taste. It is cool that someone is out there making them and I am sure there is an audience for them, but it is not for me. Most of these games are clearly not made under professional circumstances. They have all the tells of amateur works. And as with a lot of amateur fiction, most of it is pretty horrendous — if not outright painful. You have to wade through tons of shoddy products before you get to the few diamonds in the rough. 

    To my surprise, there was one game that I actually got kinda hooked on — genuinely. I played it to completion, bought the second season and replayed the entire thing again. That game was Being a DIK.

    It’s incredible the places you need to look in order to find integrity these days

    What’s on display

    Being a DIK is about going to an American college, joining a fraternity and starting a new life away from home — all while getting into a variety of sexual escapades in the process. The game is part and parcel of a specific type of adult game. It is made in Renpy — an engine made specifically with visual novels in mind — and uses realistic 3D models for its visuals. And that might be the first barrier to entry.

    I do not know what program is used to generate these models, but it treads dangerously close to the uncanny valley. Probably not the optimal outset for a game that is meant to be titillating. While the look of the game and its characters is certainly meant to come off as hot, I am personally more interested in how the game tries to sell me on its central premise.

    The real power fantasy is being at college party without wishing you were at home playing video games

    This game is about the fantasy of being a frat boy fuckboy. A significant part of the game is set at parties, having drunk conversations with friends and strangers while listening to license-free pop music. In a bold design choice, you experience these parties in freeroam segments distinct from the visual novel style of the rest of the game. Imagine old adventure games like Nancy Drew and you are basically there, sans puzzles. You move around a location — screen to screen — and click on people and objects in order to advance to the next segment.

    The thread that keeps the entire game together is a surprisingly robust system of choice & consequence. Most prominently, there is an alignment system ripped right out of a Bioware joint. While Commander Shepard could be either a Paragon or a Renegade, the choice offered to you is between being a DIK or a CHICK. Clichéed machismo will grant you DIK-points, while basic empathy and rational decisions will label you as beta cuck male.

    The blatant bias in the naming scheme alone amuses me. If your choice is between acting out the literal title of the game and being a chick, it’s kinda hard to not feel like the game is making a value judgement on your behalf.

    Commander Shepard could never hit that ganja

    Big DIK Energy

    The game has five main heroines with corresponding routes. Each of them are predisposed toward one of the alignments. For example, the outgoing party girl, Sage, likes responses that add to your DIK scorer, while the high class Jill prefers gentlemanly behaviour that pulls you toward the CHICK status.

    So with five heroines, how would you think they are distributed between alignments? Two for each with one neutral? Or maybe an uneven split so three for one and two for the other? That could make sense.

    What if I told you that a whopping 4 out of 5 girls prefer you being a CHICK over a DIK? It is only Sage who approves of fratboy behavior. If you try to actually play the game as framed, you are essentially funneled into one specific route. And to add insult to injury, that route will almost certainly be sabotaged from the onset.

    No matter your disposition, you get a major choice in season 1 on whether to sleep with a teacher. This choice is unavoidable, and heavily incentivized. The central thrust of the first season is passing a hazing process for being admitted into the fraternity. One of the tasks given is fucking a teacher and another is banging a feminist. Your gender studies professor fulfills both criteria, all while being hot and into you.

    Why, wouldn’t you do it? If you reject her advances the game rubs it in relentlessly. What are you, some kinda CHICK? And this doesn’t seem like a major deal, you can bang people left and right without too much consequence, even if you are pursuing someone specific. Sage — the girl who favors DIK choices — openly doesn’t have much issue with you being a slut.

    One of the main routes actually go into the ethics of dating your teacher (not this one though)

    But let me tell you, if you go through with this choice Sage will break up with you come season 3.

    It does not matter what other choices you have made or how many affinity points you have earned with her. For story-related reasons, sleeping with the teacher is an absolute dealbreaker to her. It is not an early choice that locks you out of her route. Oh no, you still strike up a relationship, fall in love and dream of your future together. It is a timebomb that is armed to go off after you have decided that she is the one.

    I played hours of an amateur goon game, got kinda hooked on the story, waited a year for the release of the next standalone season, bought it for 20 American dollars, only for the girl I had picked to slap me in the face and call me a bastard for ruining her life.

    Jerking my chain

    For what it’s worth I find this hilarious. I don’t think I’ve ever had a game pull this sort of joke on me. Games are rarely comedic at the expense of the player. And the notion that this title — the game where the narrative spends 80 % of its wordcount jerking you off — would suckerpunch you like this? It’s amazing. I laugh just thinking about it.

    Imagine if Mass Effect pulled a trick like that. Oh, you wanted to romance Tali? Tough luck sucker, should not have saved the Rachni back in ME1!

    It reveals the truth behind choices in this game. Success is primarily determined by avoiding these pitfalls. This is not Tokimeki Memorial, where you have to play flawlessly to make Shiori Fujisaka confess to you. If you pick a lane in Being a DIK and laser focus on a specific girl, it’s trivial to get the ending you like (pending future seasons I guess). The toughest hurdle will be going through 80 % of the content, purposely avoiding any extra scenes and emotional stakes. Doing this you miss out on the majority of content, but hey, you get the girl right?

    The mechanical reason why the disparity between alignments and the harsh consequences for choices can work, is the existence of a less obvious route choice. You can choose to be uncommitted and not pick a heroine at all. While this might seem like it would be a neutral route, in truth it’s more like the true DIK route. If you want to make a playthrough where you max out on content, this is the easiest way to do so. If you get booted out of a heroine route, you can always pivot to the confirmed bachelor lifestyle.

    The game tracks an outrageous amount of choices, stuff that wasn’t immediately apparent to me before I peaked at a guide. As an example, once you get in an actual relationship with one of the main girls, the game begins to track an infidelity score. Your girl won’t raise a fuss if you give another gal the ol’ elevator look, but if you continuously act like a sleazebag your relationship will fall apart.

    You can technically fool around with other heroines, before committing to one. Wanting to optimize, I tried to make a perfect playthrough where I had done the prerequisites for all routes and made a save before the final choice of route. But you can’t really do that, since a lot of the choices I had made before the route split affected the girls’ expectations toward me.

    Zoey is actually kinda interesting. She’s a wild card, hidden heroine that only appears come Season 3

    Turns out, people resent being strung along. Funnily enough, the »Golden Path« — if Being a DIK can be said to have something like that — is straddling the line between being a fuckboy and getting the girl in the end. If you pick the exact right options you can balance being flirtatious and still having a shot at true romance. But ultimately, why would you? Why would you play the game about being fuckboy, and then not fuck around. The player incentive has been put on inside out. It’s the sort of baffling design choice I love about amateur games.

    Playing the game as intended, you are basically funneled down the path of narrative blue balls. If that is intended as an incentive to replay the game, then I gotta hand it to the game. I am just not sure if the game is quite so elegant in its design.

    This game is the funniest shit. Yeah, sure. You can DJ for no apparent reason. Does it do anything? No.

    Help, I am trapped in a slide puzzle factory and I cannot get out!

    For a game with so many nested choices and different outcomes, it’s tedious to the extreme to replay the game. To add to the illusion of more mechanical depth, the game includes a ton of mini-games that swing from being somewhat engaging to outright timewasters. Tracking your academic performances with puzzles is fitting the first time, but having to repeat them on subsequent playthroughs quickly becomes mindnumbing. Do not get me started on the fucking brawler mechanics, where you have to grind for better stats.

    Season 2 and 3 add a flagship mechanic for each season, revolving around managing the frat’s activities. These actually work pretty well, adding to the stakes of the main story, while working as a non-intrusive break from reading through dialogues. There’s also a handful of one-off minigames, like playing tennis or beer pong, which serve as nice distractions and tone-setters (partly due to being pretty trivial).

    I do think dumb puzzles in a goon game counts as another meta joke on it’s own

    What takes the crown for tedium is earning money. There is an entire ecosystem of things you can spend money on and ways to earn it, and it is painfully dull. The story offers few avenues for getting dosh. The only way to consistently pull in cash is performing the most braindead puzzles you can imagine. Let me tell you, I have become unbelievably efficient at doing 3×3 slide puzzles. To play Being a DIK optimally, means taking a break as often as possible to perform the same trivial activities again and again and again. Oh, did I mention the brawler minigame is one of the primary sources of income? Yeah, the one where you have to grind. Haha… fuck this game.

    On a new game, you are given the choice to opt-out of minigames. I can only take that as an admission that their inclusion is cumbersome. The issue is that turning off minigames autofails you in certain situations. And more importantly, you are locked out of earning money. You can still find money in the free-roam sections, but needing to play a shitty hidden object game in order to pay for dinner is, again, at odds with repeat playthroughs.

    Eventually, your primary source of income will be breeding and selling goldfish.

    The Chud Factor is off the charts

    Should you play this game? Probably not, unless you enjoy schlocky smut. Even so, be advised that the views of the author shine through the writing and it is not always pleasant. That is actually part of why I enjoy the work of amateur writers. Even when they try to write as generically as possible, they cannot avoid leaving an imprint.

    Being a DIK is a basic story of wish fulfillment. The interesting thing to me is what wishes the author thinks I want fulfilled. Like take the main character. He is meant to be a blank canvas to insert yourself into. You can influence his disposition, but as it goes, a lot of his personality has been prepared from home. He was raised by a single dad. He is down-to-earth and values honesty and hard work. It all sounds very nice when you put it like that, but it is also a suspiciously good fit for a chud’s idea of an ideal guy. The no-bullshitter who »gets things down«. You do a lot of questionable things, but it’s always presented as justifiable because the MC never has bad intentions. Even if you play as a CHICK, you are more like a Nice Guy, than a genuine, emotionally mature college student.

    You won’t believe how many guys you can punch in this game and it’s barely acknowledged

    The main character is also smart, but — more importantly — not academically inclined. He wants to study engineering, because that is real and practical. There is an extended segment where you end up in a Gender Studies course on accident and the entire comedic bit is how gross and out of touch feminists are. There is a whole gallery of feminist side-characters who are all overweight with coloured hair. The game goes to great length to hammer in just how unpleasant these girls are — especially in contrast with the conventionally attractive main characters. It is unpleasant to read, but probably not in the way the author intended.

    And have you guessed the main characteristic of our main guy? He has a big dick. You will not believe how big this dick is. Or how attracted the girls on campus are towards it. You will constantly be told just how big this dick is. Like, it is a plot point that the main character can be recognized due to his big dick. It is simply that big. And okay, I get it, game. My guy has a big dick. Cool?

    There is nothing overtly problematic about the game. For example, I have not found anything outright bigoted. Something is just constantly a bit off. One of the main heroines is a lesbian and you can convert into being bi. When stuff like that adds up, I begin to have my doubts. For what it is worth, my take is less that the author is a bigot in disguise and more that they are not as sensitive to LGBTQ-issues as they probably should be — especially if they include queer people in their adult game.

    So why?

    Good question. The reason why I have not been able to put this game out of my head is not because the smut is especially titillating or because the writing is just that interesting.

    But there is something. The framework for choice and consequences in this game is genuinely impressive. My previous example might have given you the wrong impression. It is not just punitive at random. Sleeping with the teacher is heavily signalled to be a bad idea. The game basically tells you that this choice will have major, unforeseen consequences. I just assumed it would strike at some part of the narrative that I did not care for. The reason why it works is because the emotional weight of the consequence matches the scale of the choice. The game managed to hit me where it hurts. That is applaudable.

    When the game works at its best, is when you cannot gauge exactly how choices will impact your current situation. One of the most interesting paths in the game is arguably Josy and Maya. You can pursue both girls throughout season 1, only to find out that they are actually a couple who unbeknownst have cheated on each other with the same guy. You can respect their relationship, while still pursuing one or the other. OR you can insert yourself into their relationship, becoming something of a throuple. To do so you need to fulfill requirements with both girls, and if you become part of their relationship, you also need to balance the attention you give to them. If you favor one or the other, they break up with each other, but possibly allow for you to still be involved with one of them.

    This is excluding the path where you are simply pining for them, without having become officially involved with them in the first place. The exact amount of permutations of the Josy/Maya path is probably less than I imagine in reality, and the final resolution has so far been set to conclude in future seasons. Another example is Jill’s best friend, where I am pretty sure you have to date Jill first and break up with her, before you can get a shot with her. I haven’t been able to figure out the exact steps to kiss with her, even after multiple runs through the game.

    One of the tricks the game pulls is that the outcome of choices are often dependent on your alignment as well. A lot of girls enjoy flirting, but very poignantly *not* if you have a positive DIK score. They like the attention, but not if you have a reputation for sweet-talking anyone with two legs and a pretty face. A lot of these games incentivize an unearnest playstyle. The Renpy engine even makes it trivial, since you can effortless roll back dialogue if you picked a wrong option and quick-saving is readily available. But to succeed in Being A DIK, you need to do some honest-to-god roleplaying. You cannot actually scum your way through the game.

    The thing that impresses me about this game is that all this was not necessary. This could just have been a straight-forward VN-type deal. Throw in a few choices and track affinity points for the main heroines, with a simple route split ⅔ of the way into the game. I cannot imagine how much work it must have been to plan all the dependencies in a way that still feels natural and dramatically appropriate. But they did anyway.

    They have arguably crafted one of the most complex goon games. If that is not worth a critical examination, then I do not know what is.

    Addendum: The depressing reality

    I had originally written this piece around the time the Cornell Case was hitting the news. I was only vaguely cognizant of the story. It was only covered by Danish media after the case was reopened in September 2026, long after I had played this game. I cannot in good consciousness upload a piece about college fraternities without recognizing the violence that is actively being wrought on US women.

    As a writing exercise, this entire thing was just supposed to be a fun little observation about finding surprising depths in something I had expected to be shallow. Only after doing the entire write-up did I read up on the facts of the Cornell Case. 

    I have always found depictions of American college life to be pretty unappealing and fraternities to be especially disagreeable. With the Cornell Case in mind I find the fantasy that this game presents to be entirely repugnant. It glamorises a culture that violates women. I still think this game is interesting design-wise, but just know that I do not endorse how it depicts its subject material.

    I am not sure if it is appropriate to write about a game featuring light-hearted sexual encounters at college. I originally shelved this piece because of this. If you are reading this, it is because I decided enough time has passed that it does not feel wildly inappropriate. Some part of me wants to divorce the game from everything surrounding it, but I am not sure that will ever be possible.

    I still think this game is a neat nugget of narrative design, but I could not write about it in good consciousness without acknowledging the harm done to all the Jane Doe’s of the world.

    So I would like to balance out this piece out and give proper recognition to the Cornell-case by linking to these articles on the case: